|

Mental Health Stigma in the News

Sure enough, last week, one of the first tidbits of information that was given by the military, thus becoming the focus for the tragic shooting at Fort Hood was that the shooter, Ivan Lopez, had been treated for “mental health issues”.

John Grohol has the run down of the various news stories that came out in the wake of that information, blaming these mental health issues, or the lack of proper mental health care, as the reason for the shooting, when in fact, that probably had nothing to do with it. He also explains that the issues he had sought help with, probably had nothing at all to do with this.

We talk a lot about encouraging people to get help when they are suffering from PTSD, depression or any other form of mental health problem, but then we turn right around and make these connections between those who might have mental health problems, and violence.

Imagine if we told people that they should speak out about being victims of abuse so that they can get help in healing, and then every time a violent act occurred, we proclaimed that it must have been a result of them being abused as children, because “you know how those people are”. Would any one want to come forward and admit that they are, in fact, one of “those people”? Yet the media does the same thing with mental health issues all the time. Sure Ivan Lopez spent time in Iraq, and had sought treatment for some sort of mental health issues. So do thousands of other people, every day. Are they all just a mass shooting waiting to happen?

I don’t think so.

 

Similar Posts

  • Flipboard Magazine

    If you are a Flipboard user on your iPhone or iPad, you can now get all the content from this site, as well as various links that I share throughout the week, in the Child Abuse Survivors magazine. You can subscribe in the app, or on the web, and then follow along with the things…

  • Dehumanization

    Back in November, as we were making our way around the Colosseum in Rome, I couldn’t help but think about the thousands of people who died in this arena. At the time, this was considered “entertainment” and used to sate Rome’s mob. I began to think about our modern-day culture and how things were different…

  • Sadness

    Saw this morning that Doc Searls’ mother had passed away yesterday. I think Doc’s words about it are a fitting tribute to a woman who lived a full life and left an impact on many lives. I think the words from this post by Sandee about her friend passing away from cancer sum up exactly…

  • The One Where I Compare Myself to a Rock Star

    Yeah, I know, I’m no rock star. 😉 But recently I was reading an article about Moby, and the reasons that he is done with touring, and I really could identify with what he was talking about. “I’ve never gone on a tour and not experienced anxiety, depression and insomnia. In the early days, it…

  • |

    When it Comes to Abuse, Trafficking, and Violence, Do We Have a Race and Gender Problem?

    What I want to address, however, is how our society defines victims and how it leaves far too many people behind. The article above is a great example. How many people, if asked about sex trafficking, picture little white girls or women abducted from Target? Probably a lot. For many, the only information they’ve ever gotten about trafficking are warnings about Target or shopping mall parking lots from their Facebook friends. They don’t know how many teenage boys from broken homes, living in poverty, are pulled into being trafficked. How many gay youths, rejected by their families, fall victim to it? How many immigrant children here, with no parental supervision, are sold off by the people who should be protecting them from sexual slavery? 

    Those stories, even if they’re told, are not going to grab national headlines. They are not going to evoke world-wide outrage and sympathy. Those are things that happen to “other people”. We might even be tempted to start looking for reason why it’s their own fault, or at least the parents fault, right? 

    From a media perspective, we also have to keep this in mind. An abduction of a young white girl from her home, is a rare event. It’s actually newsworthy because it happens so rarely. When it happens, it’s shocking. A trans, minority, teen being coerced into selling themselves, with no one to turn to for protection, isn’t any of those things. A gay male teen being kicked out of their parents house and trying to make it through homelessness, is also not something that happens so rarely that there would be major news coverage of it. These things happen all of the time. So often, that they aren’t really news. 

    So, which group should we have support and services for? I’d like to vote for ALL OF THEM. But that will take educating people about the reality of who gets abused, who gets trafficked, and for us all to accept that it happens everywhere. Until we get there, and are willing to see all different types of people as victims, we will continue to fail one group or another. That’s not acceptable. 

3 Comments

  1. Thank you MikeM. This is such an important topic. People do look at others differently when they hear of mental health issues or sexual abuse history. Some of the most successful and intelligent people in this country have been a victim of one or the other. Look at the overall statistics and it is apparent that we move within a group of people each day who have at one time or another suffered from these things. That does not mean that there is a lasting negative effect. There is sufficient scientific information to show that these people become over-achievers and have accomplished great things in life.

  2. This is a really complex one for me, having dealt with mental health issues my entire life, having served in the military and seen good people pushed out, their benefits robbed of them, after they’ve given their all. And lastly, I was on Fort Hood the day of the first shooting, and I still live in Killen, just outside of Fort Hood.

    So every aspect is as close to home as it could be, without me actually being a victim or witness of the shootings.

    I don’t think the Army’s failure to get that guy help is the reason he shot people, but it breaks my heart because there are a million cases the public never hears about, where good lives ARE destroyed by an uncaring, unflinching machine who’s ultimate purpose is to kill enemies, not care for friendlies.

    So, I guess what I’m saying is, don’t be too quick to let the Army off the hook for anything. They already have blood on their hands, and I’ve seen it with my own eyes. Causation is usually multi-faceted, anyway.

    1. Definitely not giving the military a pass on the mental health treatment of vets. There’s plenty of blame to go around there, but more just pointing out the fact that just because someone once sought treatment for depression, that we should jump to the conclusion that was the reason behind the shooting. As you said, the reasoning is multi-faceted and that lots and lots of people with depression never go on a shooting spree, so we should stop equating the two!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Your post must include a link to this post.

How does this work?
Write a response on your own website and include a link to this post. Then submit your response’s URL here. Your response may appear here after moderation. To update or remove it, edit or delete your original post and submit the same URL again. Learn more about Webmentions.