Warning About Online Screenings

ByMikeM Reading Time: 2 minutes

As the whole world has moved to being virtual, many of you may have searched for something like a depression screening online as a first step to determining if you need some assistance. I’m not saying that is wrong, but as Dr. Grohol points out, be careful with which website you decide to use. Some of them may just be trying to sell you treatment, no matter how you score:

The person who took this screening doesn’t have depression. Depression, as a clinical disorder, can only be diagnosed by a trained mental health professional — not a screening tool such as this. So a recommendation to get treatment right now is completely inappropriate. Even more inappropriate is the recommendation for online counseling.

Why are they recommending online counseling, specifically? Because apparently this website was setup solely as a referral funnel to one of the large online counseling services. The website owner gets a referral fee every time someone signs up through this page.

His experience on this site, which was one of the top ranked according to Google, which would indicate that Google is falling a bit short in it’s efforts to find sites with expertise and authenticity, should serve as a warning for any site that we may be visiting. Whether you’re looking for a real screening tool, or looking for reliable mental health information, or wanting to share good information to your social connections, pay attention to the website you’re on. Actually look at the site, make sure it’s a person or organization you can identify, and ask yourself if they have either a vested interest in getting you to believe something, like you need immediate treatment, or if they are completely unidentifiable and offering “expert advice” on a website that shows no connection to the subject, maybe think again about trusting what they have to say.

At the very least, ask yourself, why are they writing this? What is their goal, and am I in agreement with that goal? In this case, a depression screening tool that tells everyone they need online therapy, which they just so happen to get a fee for every new person referred? That’s pretty obvious, assuming you take a minute to look at the details.

Dr. Grohol provides some of those details in his article. I’d recommend learning what to look for.

Similar Posts

November 18 – International Survivors of Suicide Loss Day

November 18 – International Survivors of Suicide Loss Day

ByMikeM Reading Time: 1 minute

It’s a day where people who’ve suffered loss due to suicide can get together, organized by the AFSP. From their website: Survivor Day is the one day a year when people affected by suicide loss gather around the world at events in their local communities to find comfort and gain understanding as they share stories of…

Reading – How To Tell Your Partner You’re Depressed

ByMikeM Reading Time: 1 minute

This is really good advice. As with anything, I may not agree with every detail, and certainly every detail may not be realistic or work for you as an individual, but I think these are all good things to think about, and communicating with your partner when dealing with something like depression is always a…

Link – Depression not a single disease: experts

Link – Depression not a single disease: experts

ByMikeM Reading Time: 1 minute

They may be on to something – “A group of international psychologists have challenged the classification of ‘major depression’ and argue it would be better managed if it was broken down into 12 separate disorders. “We argue that depression is not a single disease, it is a heterogeneous syndrome, with patients differing remarkably in symptom…

Sharing – What Do I Do When Mental Health Coping Strategies Don’t Work?

Sharing – What Do I Do When Mental Health Coping Strategies Don’t Work?

ByMikeM Reading Time: 1 minute

Sometimes our coping strategies need to adjust to these new realities. That doesn’t mean you are failing, it means you need to adapt. It’s no different than what I often encounter at work, where the technology we work with and assist clients with changes and evolves, and we need to change and evolve with it. What we did yesterday isn’t going to work in today’s reality.

The same is true for our mental health toolkit. We need to keep evolving with it to adapt to changes.

Study Shows That Limiting Your Life to Only “Positive” Friends May Be Hurting You
|

Study Shows That Limiting Your Life to Only “Positive” Friends May Be Hurting You

ByMikeM Reading Time: 2 minutes

As it turns out, tuning out people who might need some compassion is simply an act of isolation, and isolation is almost never good for our own mental health. By cutting out the people who don’t always offer up those positive vibes, we wind up disconnected and lonely. Which, of course, we can’t share with the people left around us, because we are all living in the nothing negative bubble, so you are now living a very isolated life, which leads to much MORE anxiety, stress, and depression. 

One Comment

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.