Review: Holby City – Walk The Line (2011, UK)

Holby City is a long running, soap-style hospital drama that runs almost without a break all year round – currently in “season” 13. The end of the episode from 2nd August 2011 introduced Andy, an old school friend of a regular character, Dr Greg Douglas, who disclosed sexual abuse at the hands of a soccer coach back in their native Ireland after being admitted following a collapse. There are multiple interconnected storylines in this show but naturally we’re concentrating on the CSA story, written by Dara Fainaru.

Aside from not making the fictional paedophile in question a Catholic Priest that is when any attempt at quality drama ends in service to the soapy storyline. After the confession and twist when Dr Douglas sees a prison transfer in Greg’s notes and diagnoses the source of Andy’s latest seizure, This culminates in a literal cliffhanger near the end, which is used solely to force an implied disclosure from Dr Douglas.

If this storyline does proceed any further with the permanent character, you will have to wade through several other plots to get there and it wasn’t revisited in the following week’s episode on 16th August. Maybe there’s an element of realism in having a survivor go on to make a non-contact offence in downloading child abuse images. This stays in line with 2004 research statistics – but ER’s handling of child abuse in its final season two years ago was much better, without the difference in budget to blame. If the storyline develops any further and doesn’t get any worse, we’ll come back to it in a future review.

– CBG

Similar Posts

  • Parallel Savile CSA Enquiry Named PR Consultant Max Clifford In Historical Allegations

    As far as we’re concerned this is not the biggest news story of last week, which broke on Friday 27th April. Clifford’s naming follows that of Jim Davidson, Freddie Starr and Rolf Harris. The allegations are reported with the usual prurience disguised as public interest and the assumption of being in an alternative judiciary and there is no small hint of…

  • This Week’s Links (weekly)

    Creating Outrage: Three Factors That Predict The Public Response To Male Sexual Assault Victims tags: CA ChildAbuse Common Symptoms in Adult Survivors of Childhood Sexual Abuse tags: CA ChildAbuse ‘That’s when the gun went off’: Ex-NHLer shares ‘raw’ story of suicide attempt tags: CA Depression Sports NHL CHILD ABUSE OR CONFRONTING ABUSE – WHAT’S THE…

  • Sharing – How Feeling Not Good Enough Makes You Crave Validation

    I also want to point out that this sense of being enough, having an internal sense of self and worth, is an important part of keeping children safe. Kids constantly on the lookout for external validation, are easier targets for grooming and abuse.

    How would you develop this sense of self in yourself? I have some ideas, but I want to hear from all of you too.

  • Does Childhood Trauma Disrupt Our Storytelling Abilities?

    I will admit, in healthcare, these two types of narrative incoherence could cause a problem. How would a medical professional move forward with a diagnosis when our response to the first question is to dump an overwhelming amount of possibly relevant, possibly not, information, or to dismiss any symptoms? It really would be difficult to know. We know that the folks who get to the quickest, and best, healthcare are the ones who come in with details like what is wrong, how long it’s been going on, what happened previously to an illness or injury, etc. Trauma survivors typically struggle with exactly that.

    This is only one way where not being able to tell a story in a coherent, effective, way hurts survivors. It blocks us from legal proceedings, as I said before, and it blocks us from being understood by those closest to us quite often. So, if you really want to connect with others, and maybe get better healthcare, learn to tell stories. That’s how the world communicates. But, if you’re confronted with someone who is struggling to tell a coherent story, consider what kind of trauma they may be dealing with, and have a little patience.

  • |

    Links (weekly)

    Finding hope after sexual abuse tags: CA Blog Against Child Abuse – January 2012 Edition tags: CA As Victims, Men Struggle for Rape Awareness tags: CA Sexual Abuse in youth sports: 10 tips for keeping children safe tags: CA 5 Strategies to Soothe Stress tags: CA Posted from Diigo. The rest of my favorite links…

  • Sharing – The Way We Show Up

    How we show up for other people matters. We can provide that place of safety in which they can heal and flourish. Too often, we don’t, though. We don’t know what to do, so we don’t show up. We don’t understand the importance of showing up, even if it’s not perfect, just to let people know that they are not alone in difficult situations. Everything is harder when you go through it alone, so show up for your people. 

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

To respond on your own website, enter the URL of your response which should contain a link to this post's permalink URL. Your response will then appear (possibly after moderation) on this page. Want to update or remove your response? Update or delete your post and re-enter your post's URL again. (Find out more about Webmentions.)